But most restaurants from Key Largo to Key West use only the real deal in some of the tastiest key lime pies around. Not only do they serve traditional slices of key lime pie that are homemade, they also serve slices dipped in chocolate on a stick in addition to giant cookies and delectable marble slab fudge. A firm favorite on Duval Street, if beating the heat is what you’re after, make sure to also sample the shop’s creamy key lime ice cream. An iconic piece of Key West’s history, the Green Turtle Inn, known locally as “The Turtle”, is beloved for its Southern-style cuisine and Old Florida charm. Florida has always been the home of Key-lime pie, so politicians made it the official state pie in 2006. By clicking 'X' or continuing to use the site, you agree to allow cookies to be placed. You will see frozen, chocolate covered key lime pie all throughout the Keys, but Kermit’s is one of the best. and privacy policy. History of Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys. Careers, For our final selection, we’re going back to the classic ingredients of this Florida … Furthermore, they’re so tiny that you’d need to juice at least twenty of them for this recipe. It’s tarty lime flavor and thick crust is sure to satisfy your taste buds, while the chocolate covered key lime pie slice, cookies and fudge are great for sweet lovers. For many Miamians, that includes a visit to Key Largo's Fish House. For more than two decades, Kermit's has been serving some of the finest key lime pie, courtesy of Kermit Carpenter. Key lime pie isn’t just a local favorite, it’s the official state pie of Florida. At this Marathon restaurant, originally known as Bill Thompson's Villas & Marina, slices are deep-fried and arrive with a crisp crust and subtly sweet filling drizzled with a raspberry reduction and topped with whipped cream ($5.95). In Texas, it's brisket. By subscribing I agree to the terms and privacy policy. Contact Us, Made daily with fresh squeezed limes and a graham cracker crust, it is served with a heaping portion of meringue on top. Topped with fresh whipped cream made in-house just before its served, you’ll be hard-pressed to not want to take a slice home as a souvenir. Dating back to 1909, Pepe’s Cafe in Key West is considered the oldest eating house in the area. This classic key lime pie features a graham cracker crust and mango and raspberry coulis swirls. The aesthetic is thanks to owner Niall Bowen and his wife, Elzbieta Krysztofiak, who've decorated the shop to exude Old Florida charm. But don't miss Carpenter's brilliant invention: a frozen slice skewered on a stick and dipped in dark Belgian chocolate ($4.50). They also serve a popular key lime freeze, which is a secret recipe and milkshake-like drink that is great for beating the heat. Exuding an Old Florida charm in Key West, the Old Town Bakery makes homemade key lime pies the old-fashioned way. Privacy, He also sells Key lime pie-infused soaps and salsas. Actually you have about as much chance of finding Elvis alive as you have going somewhere that doesn’t serve Key Lime Pie. The Best Ever Florida Key Lime Pie Recipe The Florida Journey Mini Key Lime Pies With Easy Homemade Whipped Cream Key lime pie is made with real key limes to create a tart, sweet, smooth, delicious pie that you will remember and crave for the rest of your life. Green Turtle Inn, Islamorada. Helmed by executive chef Andy Papson, the resort's dessert chefs start with a pecan and white chocolate crust that balances the zesty lime flavor. But we can show you how to whip up a tangy dessert straight from the Florida Keys! Named for the small citrus fruits said to have been introduced in the area in the 1830s by Henry Perrine, a botanist and diplomat who discovered the plant in Mexico, this tart and creamy dessert can be found on almost every menu in the Sunshine State. Back at home, enjoy the same great taste with an authentic key lime pie shipped directly to you. This bakery on … Enjoy the live music and laid-back vibes, then sample the much-loved key lime pie. The cafe is an homage to surfer culture with surfboards, longboards, and original '60s surf posters throughout, but if the weather is good, take your pie outside and enjoy it with your toes in the sand. A gluten-free version costs $26.99. Who said key lime pie has to be traditional? We’ll send you our newsletter with travel destinations, deals, and more! Established in 1909, Pepe's has a sign boasting it's the oldest eating house in Key West, so it only makes sense it also serves some of the best traditional key lime pie … Locally owned and operated, the Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West makes a delicious array of key lime pies. Best Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys March 13, 2015 / Bruce Bilmes and Susan Boyle / 3 Comments A more than decent Key lime pie can be made with regular supermarket limes, but if you want to experience the pie at its transcendent best, try one made with the very rare Key limes. Support the independent voice of Miami and help keep the future of New Times free. For 18 years, baker Kermit Carpenter has used the real Key-lime juice (imported from Mexico), and his pies pass the test: … Of course, you should also try the key lime pie ($8). Also, I should mention that while Key Lime is really popular around the Florida Keys, you can sample a lot more than just pie. You can help by participating in our "I Support" membership program, allowing us to keep covering Miami with no paywalls. Today, finding real key limes here in South Florida isn't always easy, because crops have continually struggled to flourish. While many shops add a pile of fluff, this restaurant’s topping is whipped into curls and torched into a beautiful display of caramel brown. Ten Best Key Lime Pies In The Florida Keys 2019 Miami New Times Key Lime Pie 4 Ingredient Filling Chelsea S Messy Apron The 10 Best Key Lime Pies In Miami Purewow . Based on a recipe passed down by the co-owner’s grandmother, the shop serves key lime by the slice, whole, or frozen on a stick and dipped in chocolate. The best prices in the Keys! Visit our online store at KeyLimeShop.com to browse our products. Windstar Cruises Sale | U.S. Coastal 2022 Cruises, Windstar Star Legend | 7-Day Costa Rica Cruise, 2021 Kickoff Sale | Hilton All-Incl. The affable Carpenter will treat you to traditional pie or even a frozen chocolate-covered Key lime pie on a stick! Terms, If time is a concern, store bought graham cracker crust and whipped cream cut the time needed to about 5 minutes plus your cooking time. on the Beach is a Key West treasure all its own, with the atmosphere of a beachside café and delicious key lime pie. A favorite of Key Largo locals for the past 25+ years, Hobo’s has a tradition of serving the freshest and tastiest food in town in a casual setting. All of the desserts are still handmade, and the key lime pie is the most notable. Ordinary limes make an exceptional Key lime pie, and they are a much better alternative to bracingly tart bottled Key lime juice. (Mass Appeal) – … To find out more, visit our cookies policy and our privacy policy. Made by a longtime pastry chef, the combination of fresh lime juice and gingersnap crust creates a delightful burst of flavors. The store, founded by Carpenter, his sister Anita, and her husband, has become a Key West brand and expanded to a second shop, located on iconic Duval Street. You’ll be lured in by the rustic ambiance of Mangrove Mama’s in Sugarloaf Key with its outdoor patio lined with palm trees, as it has been a landmark for over 30 years. Get the latest updates in news, food, music and culture, and receive special offers direct to your inbox, Key lime pie at Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe, Key lime pie at Key West Key Lime Pie Company, Miami Restaurant Directory: Takeout/Delivery/Dine-in, The Ten Best Key Lime Pies in the Florida Keys, Sculpture Trail Adds Art and Color to Your Next Drive to the Keys. Is there anything more iconic than key lime pie in Florida? About Us, Nearly every major city or vacation destination in the United States lays claim to an iconic dish. It also serves some of the best traditional key lime pie around, as all of the desserts here are homemade. The main menu offers Caribbean-influenced takes on Italian classics, although you won't find anything Italian about the slice of key lime pie ($9.50): a creamy pale-yellow key lime custard nestled into a rich graham cracker crust and topped with a massively majestic crown of fluffy meringue. Located on the corner of Eaton and Grinnell Streets, former home of Cole’s Peace Bakery, Old Town Bakery makes key lime pies using fresh-squeezed key lime juice, creating a dense, beautiful, yellowish-green custard cradled in a gingersnap crust, a flavor that pairs exceptionally well with the tartness of the limes. Serving hungry patrons for more than two decades, it has gotten recognition from the likes of Food Network and National Geographic and has become a local institution. Of course, no Florida Keys menu would be complete without a slice of key lime pie, and Hobo’s does it right- real key limes, graham cracker crust, and the perfect amount of whipped cream. Best Key lime pie in Marathon, Florida Keys: Find 34,407 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of the best Key lime pie and search by price, location, and more. Everyone who's visited the Keys more than a few times develops their own special traditions of where to stop for breakfast, lunch, or a few cold drinks. 1211 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040-3129, USA. David Sloan’s experience manning the annual Key Lime Festival, aiding in the construction of the World’s Largest Key Lime Pie (with enough sweetened condensed milk to fill 990 margarita glasses) and penning the Ultimate Key Lime Pie Cookbook has made him a Key lime all-star. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe serves some of the finest key lime pies in the state. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe, Key West, Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory, Tavernier, Top 15 Under-the-Radar Travel Destinations, A Local's Guide to the 10 Best Museums in St. Petersburg, Florida, Top 15 Vacation Rentals for a Florida Keys Road Trip, Eat, Drink and Be Merry This Holiday Season at Capt. We'll send you our newsletter with travel destinations, deals, and more! As for me, I’ll be taking a break from Key Lime Pie for a while. The Green Turtle Inn has a long history in the Keys (too long to get into here, but the structure dates back to the 1930s). Blue Heaven. A sister establishment to Blue Heaven in Key West, Salute! We can’t get enough of this sweet and tangy masterpiece, created, of course, in Key West. There is no better place to get the best key lime pie than at Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe. If you're hankering for a pie, but can't drive down to Key West, you can order a pie online for $24.99. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe is the original and best key lime shop in the area. Authentic Florida Key Lime Pie is the first thing you must try when you arrive in the Florida Keys. Not to disappoint you, but the tiny yellow fruit hasn't grown here commercially for decades. Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Factory. Please fill out highlighted fields and click "Compare Prices" to continue. 200 Elizabeth Street Key West, Florida 33040. While the main menu is full of Caribbean-influenced cuisine, the key lime pie here is served traditionally with its creamy key lime custard that pairs well with a rich graham cracker crust, then topped with a generous portion of fluffy meringue. Funky Buddha's Super Bowl Commercial: "Funky the Ordinary"... Watch the Super Bowl Outdoors at These Miami Restaurants. One thing that sets a true key lime pie apart from the pretenders is the use of real key lime juice squeezed from fruit harvested from plants now native to parts of the West Indies and Mexico but with origins in Asia. The closest you'll get to the real thing is found at Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe. Florida Key Lime Pie is THE perfect summer dessert. Noted by Cosmopolitan Magazine for their delectable key lime pies, Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen in Key Largo has been operating for over 40 years. Since we started Miami New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Miami, and we would like to keep it that way. In Chicago, it's deep-dish pizza. The iconic pie is named for the small citrus fruits that are said to have been introduced in 1830 and is now considered a must-try local delicacy when visiting the Sunshine State. The sublime taste of our Award-Winning Key Lime Pie was voted "Best in Key West" by Key Lime Festival; "2016 Best in Miami" by New Times; and "Best in Florida" by Florida Monthly Magazine for several years. Named for the small Key limes that were once abundant in the Florida Keys, Key lime pie can be found at restaurants across the Keys, all of which claim to serve the very best you’ll find. Key lime tree . When I first walked into Kermit’s in Key West it took all of me not to … Each slice of key lime pie ($4.50) is tart and rich, uses real key limes, and has a graham cracker crust. Grab a slice of the classic pie or try something new, as this shop also serves pies on a stick dipped in dark or white chocolate. Established in 2010, Old Town Bakery looks like it's been around a lot longer. The Stoned Crab. The charm of the place adds the perfect touch of sweetness. The affable Carpenter will treat you to traditional pie or even a frozen chocolate-covered Key lime pie on a stick! The key lime was introduced to the Florida Keys during the 1830s by Henry Perrine, a diplomat and botanist who discovered the plant in Mexico. A trip to the Southern state would not be complete without indulging in a slice of this famous delicacy. Almost two centuries later, key lime pie can be found on almost every dessert menu throughout Florida. If you’re looking for a unique place to stay, check out the top Airbnb rentals in the area. The spot is best known for its Southern-style food and charm, including the restaurant’s signature turtle chowder, a dish the inn has been serving for decades. Nearby Hotels. CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS: California Privacy Policy | California Collection Notice | Do Not Sell My Info. I promise you won’t be long here before you notice this brilliant but simple dessert on the menu. A trip to the Southern state would not be complete without indulging in a slice of this famous delicacy. You’ll be overwhelmed with sugary choices at Mattheessens in Key West. There’s no denying it: Key lime pie is an essential staple of the Florida Keys. While waiting for your dessert to arrive you can browse the shop to find a large selection of souvenirs to take home. A Key West favorite, the Key West Key Lime Pie Company boasts award-winning pies that are made from scratch. Best Key lime pie in Key West, Florida Keys: Find 149,059 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of THE BEST Key lime pie and search by price, location, and more. Use of this website constitutes acceptance of our terms of use, our cookies policy, and our privacy policy. Starting with the very dense graham cracker crust, there was flecks of coconut and molasses flavor throughout. La Grignote. The result: a filling that's light and smooth, with just the right touch of sweetness, and a perfect ratio of creamy filling to crunchy crust. The pie is topped with fresh berries and whipped cream ($8).